18 Comments
User's avatar
Ian Paul Sharp's avatar

Reading your take on The Who’s varied and yet short discography will be a treat, Matt. ‘Who Are You’ is the subject of my next post - an incomplete look at the new boxed set.

I might - might - write a series on Genesis next year. A little relieved to see they didn’t make the cut for you!

Expand full comment
Matt Fish's avatar

Thanks Ian! I’m looking forward to your reaction for the Who discog ranking when it’s released.

Expand full comment
NickS (WA)'s avatar

I would ask if your willing to include the live albums in your ranking. Live at the Isle of Wight and Live at Leeds both get mentioned as some of the greatest live albums ever!

Expand full comment
Matt Fish's avatar

It’s a good question. Usually I don’t, but I’d consider making an exception for those honorable mentions. :)

Expand full comment
Mark Nash's avatar

Most excited for The Beatles but also looking forward to Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin

Expand full comment
Matt Fish's avatar

🙌🙌

Expand full comment
Dan Arnold's avatar

Zep

Who

Pink Floyd

Beatles

Queen

Expand full comment
Duncan McWilliam's avatar

Where’s Little Feat ?

Expand full comment
Matt Fish's avatar

🤷

Expand full comment
Ian baker's avatar

Pink Floyd. Led Zeppelin 🙏

Expand full comment
Tamara Casey's avatar

You cannot go wrong with any of these.

Expand full comment
Dan Pal's avatar

Covering the Beatles is a tall order! It will be fun though. I think I'm most interested in hearing about Queen.

Expand full comment
Matt Fish's avatar

Thanks Dan!

Expand full comment
Jon (Animated)'s avatar

This is a great choice. As a music fan seeing how smaller groups evolved because of these bigger icons always fascinated me.

Expand full comment
David Perlmutter's avatar

This is nice, but there are lesser-known artists also worthy of this treatment- but I guess that will have to wait until 2027...

Expand full comment
Matt Fish's avatar

I don’t disagree with you, and several of those names were mentioned by a handful of voters. Not enough to supplant the big dogs, in the end.

Expand full comment
NickS (WA)'s avatar

The format makes it hard for a write-in to claim a top-spot. When I voted I just picked from the available choice but, about a day later thought I should have considered the write-ins more seriously.

Expand full comment
Matt Fish's avatar

What would those have been?

Expand full comment